This is a budget action film. Some people seem to think that low budget means that bad acting and worse action scenes are excusable. Anyone whose seen a really good budget movie will know that there's really no excuse. All directors have to start somewhere of course, but this director wont be going anywhere, in my opinion. The acting in this film is truly awful. There's not much I can say to redeem it. The mood of the film flicks between over-serious and Benny hill trash comedy (an apparent attempt to reproduce the comedy style of some Japanese action films, which doesn't work). The car chase being a good example; what the hell is with the stupid music and unfunny attempts at comedy when the rest of the film is trying to be serious?!. It makes no sense and gives the feeling that the director was either high, a clueless student, or both. There are some hot babes in the film but nowhere near hot enough to make the bad acting bearable. Bas is a hero to any fighting fan but I'm afraid to say his appearance is so short I can't even recommend the film to his die-hard fans. A previous reviewer forgave this film's misgivings giving it 8 stars, and I can understand that there are times when budget movie-trash is sometimes a good laugh, but there are so many much better budget films than this that I can't find it in my heart to recommend it to anyone other than the directors mum.
那群被惊飞的密密麻麻的蝙蝠带给我的视觉震撼蛮大的，覆巢之下安有完卵，惊恐感与无措感一下子被拉满。
有些人表面上是萨摩的西乡隆盛，其实是新选组的近藤局长。
战争的真实感不是在于枪林弹雨，是缓慢的危险，是草丛中的蛇，是仓皇的逃跑或追逐，是悄无声息倒下的身躯，是给俘虏喂吃的，是在非人般的艰苦条件中选择云霄之上的信仰
涕泗橫流。
是怎样做到让一部战争片既隐忍又激烈、既克制又如此动人的？忍不住要为这部《云霄之上》点个赞！
看到大家都说差我就放心了，我坐在电影院如坐针毡，一想到一会儿导演编剧过来大家还要奉承几句…整部电影最好看的应该就是片头了，越看下去越想睡觉。融合了（自以为）诗意电影的风格，山水意境，我只看到了各种格式化，整个故事情节一眼看到底但是过程又演的让人不知所云。本来想打个新主流和诗意电影的结合招牌，没想到弄成个四不像
这真的是一段很冷门的历史，虽然现在战争题材已经非常广泛，但浙西南挺进师的历史仍是小众。
新選組作為京都維安者的劍與爪牙，選擇不隱諱它與其靈魂人物土方副長的善惡複雜性，反而襯托它的悲劇之美與崇高。打戲和文戲都快感滿點，服裝場景和時代還原度極佳，敘事沉穩中有驚喜，對歷史愛好者而言觀影全程完全停不下來，該煽情該熱血的地方都魄力十足，比起經常沉悶冗長或胡亂美化主角的傳統大河或時代劇完全不是一個檔次。能在作為載體的兩個半小時電影中塞入司馬桑這麼長篇的內容和歷史，本身就已經是幾乎不可能的任務，就實際執行完成度而言，值得高度讚賞。5+
其实不像战争片更像惊悚片。赶上这个日子，可选的片子不多，建议还是看老片吧。
剧作方面还是散了点，导致影片内涵很浅，如此拍电影，讲故事似乎成了一件形式主义的事情。
有些压抑
故事里的他们操着各地的方言对话，恰似当年来自五湖四海的红军战士们因为战争而走到了一起。
方言台词很有特色，再搭配山水环境，浙江味有了。
主旋律电影看了那么多，这一部算是很特别的，战争片审美疲劳症被治好了。
流水线的剧情导致许多历史事件展现得水过鸭背
在军令面前的挣扎和死亡，牺牲的都是活人，聚焦在个体的苦痛中。
像是我小学的时候模仿文青写的作文一样 有形无实
虽然是小成本，但完全当得起大制作，镜头语言很细腻很唯美，黑白撞色凸显战争的残酷，水墨画质感描绘祖国壮丽山河，血雨无限升华革命精神。
影片的最后画面由黑白转向猩红，战士脸上已分不清是雨还是血，这个长镜头震撼我良久，似乎什么都没说，又似乎说了很多很多。
泥土雨化作血水
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
